Well the ³Northern Alliance² is in control of much of Afghanistan .
Of course, they were getting their tails whipped until the United
States taxpayers started bombing the heck out of Taliban positions, a
technique that is believed to have cost approximately one billion
dollars a week.
Now they are somewhat pointedly telling the West ³Thank you very much for your help. Now get out.²
This
is, at a certain level, understandable. As someone pointed out, if in
1780 the French had said ³We¹re going to be leaving occupation forces
in the new country to make sure you are good boys,² Georgie Washington
and company would have reacted with less than pleasure. Despite the
notable help of the French in the way of resources and pinning down
portions of the British Navy.
However, there are vast
differences. One notable aspect of the American Revolution is that,
with very few exceptions, there was not a great killing directed at the
Loyalists. Indeed, even Loyalists who had participated in raids against
rebel colonists were accepted, if not with open arms. What did not
happen is, in retrospect, amazing. There was not widespread looting of
Loyalist farms and businesses. There was not widespread raping of
Loyalist wives and daughters. And Loyalists were not hanging from every
tree until the road from New York to Philadelphia looked like Rome
after the Spartacus uprising.
Now, the degree of
³atrocities² thus far perpetrated on the Taliban is arguable. When a
group is entrenched in a urban fortress, even one made out of a school,
and refuses to surrender, then killing 80% of them is normal and
anything but an ³atrocity.² However, the record of the Northern
Alliance Forces is well known in Afghanistan . The NLA had once been in
control of Afghanistan , many of them are the ³followers of the former
elected President Rabbani², and they spent their entire administration
raping and looting the majority Pushtun. The Pushtun are notorious for
their long memories and this was not all that long ago. There are
plenty of Pushtun women who would love to get their hands on a Tajik or
Turkic soldier for a while. They¹ve been sharpening their knives for
ten years.
Furthermore, despite their pronouncements about
a ³pluralistic government,² the leaders of the NLA have already begun
consolidating power along their tribal lines. Indeed, the followers of
the late Massood have been referred to, with justice, as a ³Panjiri
mafia.² What this means is that the entire group might be of one
ethnicity, but they are led by a single tribe within this ethnicity.
And it is that tribe, one not particularly popular among their own
ethnic group, much less among the whole of Afghanistan , which is
rushing to take power.
This would be on the order of a
small gang from a single street in Brooklyn trying to ³rule² all of New
York . It¹s been done before and it wasn¹t pretty. It¹s even less
pretty when the gang has a thousand year history of raping the women
and killing any men who protest.
We have to keep our eyes
on the prize. The point to the entire expensive exercise is to
ELIMINATE STATE SPONSORED TERRORISM FOR ALL TIME. But if we allow the
Afghans to follow their own head, it leads, inevitably, to another
Taliban. Because when the Taliban came to power they were better than
the NLA forces. Better for the country, better for the women, better
for the children. It¹s better to wear a burqua than to be raped and
murdered. When you¹re facing a binary solution set like that, you tend
to put on the friggin shawl.
What we have just done is,
effectively, turn back the clock. We have wiped out the conditions that
developed in Afghanistan over 20 years. But if the present Bush
administration now says ³Okay, we¹re done,² it will be as huge a
strategic mistake as not going to Bagdad was for his father.
His
senior policy advisers know that. But there will be tremendous pressure
to declare victory and go home. Especially when our erstwhile ³allies²
start resisting our ³suggestions.² Like ³no, you can¹t rape all the
women and sell the sheep.² And even moreso when we find ourselves
³bombing the next group of ragheads.²
Pray for President
Bush, for Condi Rice and her advisers. The tough part has just started,
politically and militarily. And remember, it¹s not when the going is
easy that a president needs friends.